02-11-2008 12:59 PM
02-12-2008 07:31 PM
02-13-2008
09:12 AM
- last edited on
04-23-2024
10:13 AM
by
Content Cleaner
NH, thanks for getting back to me so quickly. Hopefully this will provide you with detailed info as to what the problem is.
The datasheets for the three LabVIEW NTSC analog frame grabbers site resolutions of 640 x 480 in the text and in the specs site an NTSC pixel clock of 12.27 MHz, lower than the clock needed for 720 x 480 @ 30fps.
The LabVIEW digital image acquisition hardware can handle resolutions much higher than 640x480, but our video source is NTSC from a composite cable. The best analog framegrabber NI offers seems to be 640x480. If I'm overlooking a LabVIEW NTSC framegrabber that can handle this, please point it out to me! I've talked to the LabVIEW salesperson, but she offers no solution for me.
There are several possible solutions to this problem. But I would like to get a tested solution I can confirm works. We're buying LabVIEW for motor control and testing, and it would be nice to get the Vision module working so we can have an integrated solution.
Here are solutions I see:
1- Write LabVIEW driver files for the Hauppauge in-house
2- Purchase a framegrabber with a simpler interface and write LabVIEW driver files in-house
3- Purchase LabVIEW driver files to an NTSC device that captures at 720x480 @ 30fps or higher, and then purchase that device
4- LabVIEW creates a framegrabber capable of this
Option 4 I don’t see NI doing in the timeframe we’re looking at, although there are framegrabbers that can capture NTSC composite video at 720x480 @ 30fps that sell for as little as $29, it doesn’t make sense for NI not to have something comparable.
Regarding options 1 & 2, writing LabVIEW driver files in-house would be very expensive and time consuming. Other vision solutions become much more attractive at this price-point. We would like to get a tested, out-of-the-box, solution. I received this link from the labVIEW salesperson regarding creating vision drivers: http://zone.ni.com/devzone/cda/tut/p/id/4478
That leaves option 3, a third party driver. I found some solutions from Alliance Vision at http://www.alliancevision.com/us/products/softwares.htm . However, I would like to find a piece of hardware that someone else has already used with these drivers and purchase that instead of hoping that it will work with the Hauppauge (unless someone already tested it).
For option 3, LabVIEW vision $3500, driver $600, total $4100. That’s just too much for an unproven solution. I’ll pay more for something I know works.
Does anyone have a solution or know someone who created a solution?
Thanks
02-21-2008 09:40 AM