Feedback on NI Community

cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Advanced Search is Broken

1. In Internet Explorer and Chrome, I am unable to select a specific board(s) to search - see below:

 

AdvancedSearchBroken.png

 

2. I cannot have more than 1000 items in a result set, and there is a bug when you try to access more than 1000. When viewing 250 results per page, the first four pages work fine (results 1 through 1000), but page 5 onward returns an incoherent and incorrect message. (Ideally, I want it to return results, not simply a coherent message)

 

AdvancedSearchBroken2.png

3. I would like to see some more significant digits instead of "about 3000 posts". This may be a query limitation, but I suspect it's a front-end formatting issue that can be resolved easily.

 

4. Still cannot perform a search with an empty search query. This field should not be required, given other search parameters are provided (Username/ID, or Date Range, or ...). My workaround is really sloppy - the amount of HTML alone returned by the server when performing a search like this exceeds 1.2MB per page ( Smiley Surprised )

 

5. It's irksome that the only way to access the Advanced Search is by performing a quick search first. The Advanced Search link is only accessible once you're in the realm of the Search page.

 

I would love to see bugs and interface limitations in Search (and it's good buddy Sort) get bumped to Showstopper/Critical/Red Alarm/High Priority.

Message 1 of 9
(11,328 Views)

 


@JackDunaway wrote:

1. In Internet Explorer and Chrome, I am unable to select a specific board(s) to search - see below:

 

AdvancedSearchBroken.png

 


 

It turns out that you have to click on the little ">" symbol. Intuitive, it's not. I think this new interface was put in because in the previous one when you clicked on the LabVIEW board there was a text box that got filled in with 170 (the board ID), which was even less clear.

 

 


3. I would like to see some more significant digits instead of "about 3000 posts". This may be a query limitation, but I suspect it's a front-end formatting issue that can be resolved easily.


 

Frankly, I think when you have that many results it's somewhat irrelevant whether the number displayed is 3000 or 3010. I mean, what difference does it make? Clearly it indicates that your search query is too vague.

 

 


4. Still cannot perform a search with an empty search query. This field should not be required, given other search parameters are provided (Username/ID, or Date Range, or ...). My workaround is really sloppy - the amount of HTML alone returned by the server when performing a search like this exceeds 1.2MB per page ( Smiley Surprised )

 

Are you're referring to the Advanced Search page? I'm able to enter a search without a search query. For example, I can search for all posts by me.

 

 


5. It's irksome that the only way to access the Advanced Search is by performing a quick search first. The Advanced Search link is only accessible once you're in the realm of the Search page.


AGREED!!!!

 

Message 2 of 9
(11,294 Views)

 


@smercurio_fc wrote:

 

It turns out that you have to click on the little ">" symbol. Intuitive, it's not. I think this new interface was put in because in the previous one when you clicked on the LabVIEW board there was a text box that got filled in with 170 (the board ID), which was even less clear.

 

 


It took me a few minutes to figure out what you meant.  I can't even see the arrows on my monitor.  Can we get some more contrast? 

 

--
Tim Elsey
Certified LabVIEW Architect
0 Kudos
Message 3 of 9
(11,288 Views)

@smercurio_fc wrote:

 


@JackDunaway wrote:

1. In Internet Explorer and Chrome, I am unable to select a specific board(s) to search - see below:


 

It turns out that you have to click on the little ">" symbol. Thanks for this tidbit, I didn't know you could expand the categories to view the boards. But still, even now that I can see the boards, I cannot figure out how to filter based on board!  Intuitive, it's not. I think this new interface was put in because in the previous one when you clicked on the LabVIEW board there was a text box that got filled in with 170 (the board ID), which was even less clear. Yes, I remember discussion on this confusion - that's the text box that used to be populated that is now missing (see picture above).

 


3. I would like to see some more significant digits instead of "about 3000 posts". This may be a query limitation, but I suspect it's a front-end formatting issue that can be resolved easily.


 

Frankly, I think when you have that many results it's somewhat irrelevant whether the number displayed is 3000 or 3010. I mean, what difference does it make? Clearly it indicates that your search query is too vague. Information comes in many forms. 😉 From ground level, I agree completely, but at 10k feet up these assumptions are no longer relevant.

 


4. Still cannot perform a search with an empty search query. This field should not be required, given other search parameters are provided (Username/ID, or Date Range, or ...). My workaround is really sloppy - the amount of HTML alone returned by the server when performing a search like this exceeds 1.2MB per page ( Smiley Surprised )

 

Are you're referring to the Advanced Search page? I'm able to enter a search without a search query. For example, I can search for all posts by me. You're right - supplying Username/ID relieves the requirement of a search query, but simply specifying board and date range does not relieve the constraint. I was too generic with my anecdote. Point remains though - I would love a less constrained interface for searching, like it used to be before the upgrade!

 

 


5. It's irksome that the only way to access the Advanced Search is by performing a quick search first. The Advanced Search link is only accessible once you're in the realm of the Search page.


AGREED!!!!

0 Kudos
Message 4 of 9
(11,286 Views)

One invaluable addition to the Advanced Search criteria would be "Read/Unread/All". This would allow you find something you know you've read, or in another instance find the answer to some question you're honing in on.

0 Kudos
Message 5 of 9
(11,270 Views)

@elset191 wrote:

 


@smercurio_fc wrote:

 

It turns out that you have to click on the little ">" symbol. Intuitive, it's not. I think this new interface was put in because in the previous one when you clicked on the LabVIEW board there was a text box that got filled in with 170 (the board ID), which was even less clear.

 

 


It took me a few minutes to figure out what you meant.  I can't even see the arrows on my monitor.  Can we get some more contrast? 

 


Definititely.  Those arrows are practically invisible.

 

Did these changes to Advanced search happen very recently.  I don't use Advanced search all that often, once every few days to a week.  But it just so happened that I was struggling with the same problems as Jack just hours before I saw his post.  I never did narrow my search to the LV board like I wanted because I never saw the way to select it.

 

Actually, the headers appeared to be selectable (pointy hand, underlined text when hovering over it), but clicking on it did nothing.

 

Now I can see (just barely) how you open up the tree to get to the sub levels.  But even now, they appear to be selectable, but clicking on them does nothing.

0 Kudos
Message 6 of 9
(11,267 Views)

@JackDunaway wrote:

2. I cannot have more than 1000 items in a result set,


I just received this screenshot - has the result set been limited even further?

 

FurtherSearchProblems.png

0 Kudos
Message 7 of 9
(11,213 Views)

Thanks for all of the search feedback.  I'm going to aggregate all the recent feedback I've been hearing and compare it to what I've already submitted and make sure that it's all accounted.  In addition, I'm still (too slowly) working on releasing the updated search interface that is available.  It's not necessarily a large improvement but does have some benefits to the interface.

 

Regards,

Laura

Message 8 of 9
(11,173 Views)

Uncovered another issue with Advanced Search. Since this post already existed, I figured it was better to have it one place rather than creating a new post.

 

After you perform an Advanced Search you cannot change the "Board, Blog, Idea Exchange, Contest, or Category" selection and perform the search on a new selection. It highlights the new selection, making you think it's going to perform the search in that other board, but it actually performs the search on the previous selection.

0 Kudos
Message 9 of 9
(10,762 Views)