01-24-2003 01:53 PM
01-24-2003 03:07 PM
01-25-2003 02:54 PM
01-28-2003 01:57 PM
11-17-2009 11:42 AM
11-17-2009 04:30 PM
Several years ago (back in Lookout 3.8 days) there was ethernet for AB SLC-5/05, it was a choice on the pull down menu for the communications type. It works great.
then in the days of Lookout 5.X, NI removed the ethernet for AB SLC-5/05. I believe the issue was that some users were having difficulty in understanding the I/O addressing, expecially when they would have an analog input/output card in the chassie. The issue is that RSLogix 'neatly' organizes this I/O table for us, however, NI can only get the I/O table in its 'raw' form. And this caused confusion for users not experienced with how the I/O table is truly layed out. A user can experiment with a bench/test system and see how the I/O is layed out and get a good understanding. But a another method is to write the analog input value to a "N" file address, and use that in Lookout (remember only the I/O is the issue) Also, you can have Lookout write to another "N" file address, and in the SLC, move that "N" address to the Analog Ouput.
I still have a SLC file for Lookout that has the ethernet enabled (works with Lookout V5.x) but I bet Ryan can send you one if you need it.
I have upgraded to Lookout V6.2 and making a driver object to talk to AB SLC-5/05 on ethernet works great. (I love native drivers, and hate using RSLinx OEM to do OPC (for out ControLogix5000 processors)
If a person can work thru how I/O tables are truly layed out (one big matrix actually) go direct and dont' use OPC.
Remember, this isn't a fault/limitation of Lookout or NI, it is how AB layes out their I/0 table, and how the addressing we see in RSLogix is actually not the true representation of the actual matrix. (and this matrix is all that is actually available, AB just makes it more 'readable' because you (or who ever setup the chassie configuration) told RSLogix what cards are in which slot, so RSLogix can minipulate the table to show it to you more 'pretty'.
If NI would add a chassie configuration to the AB SLC driver, then this issue would not exist. But I don't think we want to do that.
Hope this was helpful!
Rich Anderson
11-18-2009 12:38 AM
The choice for slc ethernet was added in lookout 6.0. I don't remember if we had it in 3.8 before.
Rich - Is the SLC file you mentioned from lookout 3.x or 4.x software?
11-18-2009 07:43 AM
11-18-2009 08:10 AM
Ryan, the AB Object file I have is from Lookout V5 before it was removed in a later V5 (for example, I have it from 5.0 before it was removed in 5.2 [don't know for exact if the subVersion# is accurate, just an example]) But it is for V5 before removed.
Rich