NI Home
Cart Cart | Help
Hello Events Academic NI Developer Zone Support Solutions Products & Services Contact NI MyNI
You are here: 
NI Home > NI Developer Zone > NI Discussion Forums


Reply
Trusted Enthusiast
Intaris
Posts: 2,267
0 Kudos

Firewire card with multiple controllers

Quick question....

 

I am looking for a firewire card for connecting 2 cameras.  Will I be able to use a standard PCI-E card or will I need to look for one with one controller per port....  Most share a single controller voer multiple ports.  I've had problems int eh past with multiple ports on one card, but this may have been a PCI card with limited system bandwidth.....

 

Ideas anyone?

 

The cameras will be most likely 1280x1024 RGB cameras with 60FPS.

 

Cheers for any help forthcoming.

 

Shane

RFC 2323 FHE-Compliant
Trusted Enthusiast
Intaris
Posts: 2,267
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

Nobody, no?

 

The cameras are actually monochrome, 8-bit not RGB (24-bit) and only go up to 30Hz.....

 

I mean theoretically a FW400 card should handle a 1024pixel x 1280pixel x 8bit x 30Hz (314 Mbit/s without overhead) picture no problem but adding a second camera will more than saturate the bus.....

 

Anyone know of a decent PCI-E FW card which has two ports with a seperate controller for each?  Please?

 

Shane

RFC 2323 FHE-Compliant
Trusted Enthusiast
BruceAmmons
Posts: 2,289

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

I don't know any firewire cards that meet your specs, but it might work to get a firewire B card, then use cables that convert from firewire B to A.  A single firewire B controller should be able to handle both cameras easily, but I am not a hardware expert so I can't guarantee it.

 

Bruce

Bruce Ammons
Ammons Engineering
Trusted Enthusiast
Intaris
Posts: 2,267
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

Thanks Bruce,

 

That's somethinge I can give a try.

 

Kudos.

 

Shane.

RFC 2323 FHE-Compliant
Active Participant
PackersFan
Posts: 253
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

The Bandwidth Calculator here might help.

Chris
Certified LabVIEW Developer
Active Participant
Topper_Harley
Posts: 207
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

I strongly advise you to deploy a professional IEEE 1394a board for your imaging application.

 

National Instruments offers suchs interfaces for PCI, PCIe and PXI standards.

 

http://sine.ni.com/np/app/main/p/bot/no/ap/vision/lang/en/pg/1/sn/n17:vision,n21:11600,n28:1394/

Active Participant
GuenterMueller
Posts: 785
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

Hi Shane.

I once used this (when using two cards was no option due to a missing free slot in the PC).

Trusted Enthusiast
Intaris
Posts: 2,267
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

Doe these "professional" IEEE cards have full 400MBit per port, or is the bandwidth shared over all ports....

 

If shared, I fail to see the huge advantage over a "nonprofessional" card.

 

Shane.

RFC 2323 FHE-Compliant
Active Participant
GuenterMueller
Posts: 785
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

The card has 2 buses. You have 2 cameras.  Thus, you will get maximum performance for each camera as long as you connect each camera to a port that uses one bus exclusively.

Trusted Enthusiast
Intaris
Posts: 2,267
0 Kudos

Re: Firewire card with multiple controllers

Thanks Guenter,

 

The Q was meant more for the "Official" NI response, but that's cool info too.

 

Any idea where I get pricing for one of those cards? The website doesn't offer any pricing info.

 

Shane.

RFC 2323 FHE-Compliant
By using this web site, you accept the Terms of Use for this web site. Please read these Terms of Use carefully before using any part of this site. Please go here for information on ni.com's copyright infringement policy.
My Profile | Privacy | Legal | Contact NI © 2011 National Instruments Corporation. All rights reserved.    |    E-Mail this Page E-Mail this Page